Carmichael v. Ige

JEWEL SAMAD/AFP via Getty IImages
JEWEL SAMAD/AFP via Getty Images

Center for American Liberty Sues Governor Ige for Unconstitutional COVID-19 Emergency Orders

The Center for American Liberty’s in conjunction with The Dhillon Law Group, and attorney James Hochberg on behalf of plaintiffs, filed a lawsuit against Governor Ige in federal court for unconstitutional orders related to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Ige issued the emergency proclamation for COVID-19 on March 4 and continues to operate under it, despite Hawaiian law limiting a governor’s emergency powers to 60 days. Additionally, Hawaii law stipulates that Ige can only order the quarantine of those known to have a disease or suspected to have it, not a blanket order effectively imprisoning all mainland Americans who arrive to the islands.

“Governor Ige is depriving Hawaiians and those living on the mainland of their constitutional right to travel, due process, and equal protection rights by mandating that everyone who comes to Hawaii be isolated in quarantine for 14 days,” said Harmeet K. Dhillon, CEO of the Center for American Liberty. “The governor has flagrantly disregarded the United States Constitution with ten successive orders with seemingly no consideration of the Constitutional limits of his powers.”

The lawsuit alleges that Ige’s unconstitutional order deprives plaintiffs Holly and Aaron Carmichael the ability to stay in their Maui condo, Oahu resident Brooke McGowan from visiting her daughter and grandmother who live on the mainland, and Russell Hirsch the ability to tend to his house and farm in Kailua and Hilo, respectfully.

“This litigation was filed because Governor Ige has exceeded his authority with his COVID response,” Hochberg said. “Most of the Plaintiffs own property in Hawaii and are precluded from tending to their properties due to the Governor’s unlawful violations of the Plaintiffs’ civil right to interstate travel. One cannot visit her family on the mainland during times of important need. Governor Ige has unlawfully continued his lock-down of our economy.”

“The governor has flagrantly disregarded the United States Constitution with ten successive orders with seemingly no consideration of the Constitutional limits of his powers.”

 

— Harmeet Dhillon
CEO | Center for American Liberty

About the Center for American Liberty

The Center for American Liberty is a nonprofit litigation, education, and public policy organization dedicated to advancing Free Speech rights and Civil Liberties. Founded by Harmeet K. Dhillon in 2019, the Center for American Liberty offers pro-bono and low-bono legal representation to Americans whose fundamental freedoms are violated.

SUPPORT THIS CASE AND OTHER PRO-LIBERTY CASES LIKE IT BY MAKING A TAX-DEDUCTIBLE GIFT TODAY

Carmichael V. Ige Complaint

Carmichael V. Ige Civil Docket

Application for TRO

Statement of Interest on Behalf of the US DOJ

UNITED STATES’ RESPONSE TO COURT’S ORDER

DEFENDANT’S RESPONSE TO THE COURT’S EO

PLAINTIFFS’ MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF THE UNITED STATES’ STATEMENT OF INTEREST

Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for TRO

Reply in Support of TRO

First Amended Complaint

Defendant's Motion to Dismiss with Memorandum in Support

Leave a comment

The fight for liberty is only possible with the support of like-minded Americans. Please consider a tax-deductible contribution to the Center for American Liberty.
Give